The Heartland on a Plate
The Midwest is an unassuming place and doesn’t need (or want) glossy introductions. The food speaks for itself. It’s hearty, unfussy, occasionally absurd, and often so comforting that a single bite can feel like the best parts of a family reunion. Think casseroles bubbling in Pyrex dishes, sandwiches so full the ingredients spill over their buns, and pies so sweet your teeth ache from the sugar. Every state swears theirs is the best, and they’re all right. Here are twenty classic Midwestern dishes that you’ll want seconds of.
1. Hotdish
Minnesota lives on this homemade casserole. The dish consists of ground beef, a can of cream of mushroom soup, a handful of green beans, and a blanket of golden tater tots crisped just so. It’s then served in a glass dish older than the table you’re sitting at.
2. Fried Cheese Curds
This cheese is so fresh it squeaks between your teeth. Drop those curds in batter, fry them until they’re molten inside, and watch a line form at the state fair stand. Ranch sauce for dipping is non-negotiable, though some insist on marinara. The grease-soaked tray tells the story of the goodness you’ve devoured when it’s all said and done.
3. Cincinnati Chili
It looks thin, almost soupy, and smells faintly sweet with a hint of cinnamon, cloves, and a whisper of chocolate. It’s poured over spaghetti noodles and buried under a mound of shredded cheddar so high you can’t see the plate. Ask for it “five-way” and suddenly you’re juggling beans, onions, and oyster crackers.
4. Chicago Deep-Dish Pizza
A fork and knife are required for this dish. Unlike conventional pizza, the sauce is ladled on top instead of hidden beneath. With its buttery crust and heavy helping of cheese and sausage, you can’t go wrong with this interpretation of pizza. One slice weighs enough to count as dinner.
Belinda Hankins Miller on Wikimedia
5. Jell-O Salad
Like its namesake, this dish is bright, wobbly, and slightly mysterious. You take Jell-O and combine it with canned pineapple, or opt for strawberry dotted with marshmallows. Crown it with some Cool Whip. Nobody’s quite sure if it’s supposed to be dessert or a side, but either way, it’s long gone by the end of the potluck.
Internet Archive Book Images on Wikimedia
6. Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
The bun is more of a garnish than a container with this sandwich, as the breaded pork cutlet is so generous it butts out in every direction. The sandwich itself is piled high with mustard, pickles—maybe lettuce if the cook felt fancy. You can’t help but get your hands dirty before the first bite.
7. Pierogi
Polish grandmothers know best. Dough circles filled with potato and cheese, pinched tight so nothing leaks, then boiled and fried until they blister in butter. Served with sour cream, sometimes caramelized onions, the best ones taste like they came straight out of a church basement fundraiser.
8. Cornbread
Cornbread is simple, golden, and crumbly. Prepared sweet in some kitchens and savory in others, it’s served with chili or with honey butter dripping through to the plate. Midwest corn makes it taste like sunshine, which is maybe why people eat it year-round even when fields are frozen solid.
Rafael Cisneros Méndez on Unsplash
9. Goulash
Not the Hungarian variety—at least not exactly. This American interpretation consists of elbow macaroni with ground beef, tomato sauce, and maybe corn if that’s what’s in the cupboard. It’s cheap, quick, and filling, made for nights when the paycheck hasn’t been deposited yet, but the family is hungry.
Alborzagros, edit by Artoria2e5 on Wikimedia
10. Runza
Nebraska swears by it. The dish consists of a bread pocket stuffed with beef, cabbage, and onions. Some chain restaurants sling them fast, but homemade versions always win in terms of taste.
InDefenseOfToucans on Wikimedia
11. Beer Brats
Simmered in beer and onion, these sausages are then grilled until the casings snap. They’re served on a paper plate with mustard streaking across the bun. Someone always asks for ketchup and gets a look of disapproval, but hey, it’s the Midwest, and hospitality wins out.
12. Lefse
This thin, potato-based flatbread has Norwegian roots. To prepare this dish, it’s first rolled, griddled, spread with butter and sugar, then rolled again like a scroll. The taste is slightly sweet and a little smoky from the pan. You’ll often find them at your local county fairs being sold wrapped in wax paper.
13. Chicken and Noodles Over Mashed Potatoes
This dish is unapologetically carbs on carbs. Thick egg noodles are cooked in a rich chicken broth until they’re almost creamy, then ladled over mashed potatoes. It’s hearty enough to leave you semi-comatose, and while it may not look elegant, it makes up for poor presentation with the satisfaction it delivers.
14. Sloppy Joes
Ground beef in a tomato-based sauce is piled onto hamburger buns. It’s sweet, tangy, and messy—living up to its name. In more than one Midwestern school cafeteria, the smell of Sloppy Joes on the lunch line meant it was the best day of the week.
15. Chili with Cinnamon Rolls
A Nebraska school lunch staple that sounds mismatched until the first bite. Some dunk the roll straight into the chili, others alternate bites, but either way, it works. Entire childhoods have been shaped by this combination.
16. Pasties
Michigan’s Upper Peninsula holds onto this one tightly. Meat and root vegetables are tucked into pastry and baked until it’s sturdy enough for miners to carry underground. Traditionally, one end was crimped extra thick so grimy hands could hold it, then toss that part away. Today they’re sold in roadside shops and pair perfectly with ketchup or gravy.
David Johnson [1] on Wikimedia
17. Corn on the Cob
Every region has this dish, but Midwest corn in late summer tastes different. It’s sweet, crisp, and dripping with butter and salt. It’s cooked in big pots at church picnics or roasted over campfires where kernels pop and char. It’s the kind of indulgent meal you eat with both hands, butter running down your wrists.
18. Maid-Rite Loose Meat Sandwich
This one’s an Iowa specialty that confuses outsiders. Seasoned ground beef is crumbled onto a bun with no sauce binding it and no cheese melting it together. Simply a pickle and some mustard. It may be messy to hold, but fans swear it’s better than any burger.
19. Buckeyes
Don’t confuse this treat with the poisonous nut. Peanut butter balls are dipped in chocolate, leaving a little circle uncovered on top, resembling the namesake. They show up at Christmas cookie exchanges, lined up like soldiers on wax paper. They’re rich, sweet, and impossible to stop at just one.
20. Swedish Meatballs
These meatballs are smaller than the normal variety. At holiday smorgasbords, the slow cooker keeps them warm for hours. Half the Midwest secretly owes their first taste of these to a trip to IKEA, but they’ve been on tables long before the furniture store made them famous.
KEEP ON READING
