Desserts From the Past
We know that local cafe probably has some kind of crepe available for $20, but do you know what really gets the taste buds going? Grandpa desserts you’ve all but forgotten about—assuming you ever heard of them at all! Ditch those elaborate bakery creations and trendy ingredients; these old-school sweets rely on pantry staples and handwritten recipes that get people talking at the dessert table.
1. Tomato Soup Cake
Yes, canned tomato soup really does belong in dessert, and generations of home bakers have proved it time and again. Popular during the Depression era, the soup adds moisture while cinnamon, cloves, and raisins do a great job of hiding all the tomato flavor. Finish it with cream cheese frosting, and you have something special.
2. Prune Whip
Few dessert names announce their age quite as confidently as prune whip. Despite what you may think, prunes don’t just belong in grandpa’s fridge, though! This fluffy combo of stewed prunes, egg whites, and sugar was once served as a light dessert, often accompanied by custard sauce.
Photographer not credited. on Wikimedia
3. Vinegar Pie
Don’t let the name scare you away. Vinegar pie came from a time when clever cooks created dessert even when fresh fruit wasn't available. All it takes is a small amount of vinegar to provide the sweet egg-based filling with enough acidity. From there, it’ll resemble the tartness you'd normally expect from fruit. It's simple, inexpensive, and far tastier than you’d think.
4. Mock Apple Pie
This strange American classic became famous for creating an apple pie (sort of) without using a single apple. It’s actually Ritz Crackers, sugar, lemon, cinnamon, and pastry combined to make a surprisingly convincing filling. Don’t tell people what you used—they probably won’t even know the difference.
Diliara Garifullina on Unsplash
5. Apple Pandowdy
Before picture-perfect pies took over social media, there was the gloriously messy pandowdy. Apples bake beneath pastry that traditionally gets broken or pushed down into the bubbling fruit juices during cooking. Okay, the result isn't elegant, but that's why it belongs on an old-fashioned table.
6. Cherry Winks
Anyone who grew up around mid-century bake sales remembers these curious little cookies. How could you not? Cherry winks combine dates, pecans, maraschino cherries, and crushed cornflakes, with another cherry piece pressed into the top. They're colorful and unmistakably from another era.
7. Poor Man's Cake
This Depression-era cake was designed around ingredients families could actually afford, hence the name. Many versions skip milk, butter, and eggs, relying instead on raisins, spices, sugar, shortening, and water. We know it sounds bland, but its humble origins don't stop it from tasting nice and rich alongside a strong cup of coffee.
8. Hermit Cookies
Hermits once occupied the cookie jar way more than they do today. It’s a shame, too! These soft, spiced cookies traditionally have raisins along with cinnamon, cloves, and molasses. They taste just as good as they sound, and their chewy texture feels especially appropriate with fall around the corner.
9. Date Nut Pudding
Despite the name, date nut pudding is actually closer to a warm cake than anything found in a pudding cup. Chopped dates and nuts bake into a dense dessert that's usually served with whipped cream. It's the sort of sturdy sweet that belonged on countless family tables before chocolate was the default to everything.
10. Applesauce Cake
Grandpa knew there was no reason to waste a jar of applesauce when it could become dessert (something we should all adopt, by the way)! Applesauce keeps this spice cake moist while raisins, walnuts, cinnamon, and cloves give classic recipes plenty of character. It also travels well, which makes it ideal for any gathering.
11. Mayonnaise Cake
Wait…first tomatoes and now mayo? Well, why not? Mayonnaise in chocolate cake sounds like a prank, but the chemistry makes a ton of sense. Because mayo already has eggs and oil, it gives the cake richness and moisture without making the dessert taste like a sandwich! It’s a retro recipe worth keeping secret until everyone asks for seconds.
12. Brown Betty
Apple Brown Betty predates many of the elaborate desserts that eventually pushed it out of the spotlight. But you know what? We’re bringing it back! Instead of a pastry crust, sliced apples are layered with sweetened breadcrumbs or crumbs, butter, and warm spices before baking. It's uncomplicated and best with vanilla ice cream.
13. Hot Milk Cake
Hot milk cake was once the answer when someone needed a simple dessert, which is why we get so excited to see it nowadays! Heated milk and butter are mixed into a light vanilla batter, producing a tender cake that works beautifully with berries. Its plain appearance hides exactly the kind of old-fashioned baking skill older generations appreciate.
14. Cottage Pudding
Don't expect anything modern from these pudding cups. Cottage pudding is actually a simple baked cake served warm with a sweet sauce poured over the top. It’s really just lemon, vanilla, or brown sugar sauces turned into an extremely basic cake.
15. Grasshopper Pie
Nothing says mid-century entertaining like a bright green dessert! Flavored with crème de menthe, grasshopper pie was a retro dinner-party favorite thanks to its chilled mint filling and chocolate-cookie crust. Set one beside modern brownies and watch how quickly this one picks up more attention.
16. Chiffon Pie
Make no mistake: chiffon pies were impressively light and elegant long before mousse-filled desserts were commonplace. Egg whites and gelatin created the airy filling, while lemon, orange, or chocolate kept things interesting flavor-wise. It's exactly the sort of dessert Grandpa remembers sinking his teeth into when company came over.
Arnold Gatilao from Oakland, CA, USA on Wikimedia
17. Pineapple Upside-Down Biscuits
The full-sized pineapple upside-down cake gets plenty of attention, but individual biscuits deserve some limelight, too. Pineapple rings or pieces, brown sugar, cherries, and biscuit dough bake into sticky little portions with caramelized tops. They're also easier to hand out at a gathering than slicing a cake.
18. Baked Alaska
For anyone determined to have a little theatrics, Grandpa's era already had the answer: Baked Alaska! It surrounds ice cream with cake and meringue, then briefly browns the outside at high heat. The frozen center remains cold, and it’s complicated enough to impress the entire table.
19. Floating Island
For this one, you’re looking at soft poached or baked meringues sitting on vanilla custard, sometimes finished with caramel. If you really wanted to spice things up, you could’ve also topped it with toasted nuts. The ingredients are simple, but the finished dish has enough elegance to make parties an occasion.
20. Washington Pie
Despite its name, Washington pie is actually an old-fashioned layer cake. Two rounds of sponge cake are sandwiched with jam before being dusted with powdered sugar. That’s right—there’s nothing else to it! It's also deeply retro and obscure enough that even Grandpa may be impressed you remembered it.
KEEP ON READING
The 5 Most Consumed Foods in the Entire World
