Wendy Wei on Pexels

Thanksgiving dinners in the United States are known for their comforting traditions, from turkey to pumpkin pie. Among these staples, cranberry sauce often sparks debate. Is it an essential part of the feast, or just a jiggly oddity that some prefer to skip?

The story of cranberry sauce is as rich and layered as the holiday itself, weaving together history and evolving tastes. Let’s discover whether this tart tradition continues to hold meaning today.

The Great Cranberry Sauce Debate

Cranberry sauce shows up at nearly every Thanksgiving dinner, but it's far from universally loved. In fact, a 2023 survey by SurveyMonkey for The Vacationer revealed that almost one-third of Americans don't even like it. That's a pretty significant chunk of people politely avoiding the cranberry dish while loading up on everything else.

So why does it keep its spot at the table year after year? Tradition plays a big role, but that doesn't answer whether it actually belongs there. 

Why Cranberry Sauce Is So Often Disliked

The biggest complaint about cranberry sauce usually comes down to texture and flavor—especially the canned variety. That jiggly, gelatinous consistency feels unnatural next to the rest of a home-cooked meal, and the overly sweet taste doesn't quite fit with savory dishes like turkey and gravy.

Many people describe it as cloying or artificial, lacking the freshness you'd expect from a fruit-based side. Instead of adding something special to the plate, it often just sits there, feeling more like an obligation than an actual contribution to the meal.

For a lot of families, cranberry sauce ends up being that dish no one really wants, but everyone feels they have to serve. It doesn't enhance the flavors around it—it just exists separately, tolerated rather than enjoyed.

When a dish divides diners this much, it's worth asking if cranberry sauce truly earns its place next to turkey, stuffing, and mashed potatoes.

Tradition Vs. Taste

Burkhard Mücke on Wikimedia

Cranberry sauce holds onto its Thanksgiving spot largely because of tradition. Even people who don't like it often serve it anyway, feeling like the table wouldn't look right without it. There's an unspoken pressure to include certain dishes, and cranberry sauce is one of them.

But here's where it gets interesting—not all cranberry sauce is created equal. The canned jelly version gets most of the hate, but homemade cranberry sauce is a completely different experience. Made with whole berries, orange zest, and spices, it offers actual flavor and texture instead of that weird gelatinous blob.

For those who've only tried the canned stuff, a homemade version might change their mind entirely. Sometimes it's not about the dish itself, but how it's prepared.

Should It Stay Or Go?

Cranberry sauce is stuck between tradition and actual preference. Some families keep serving it because it feels like part of the holiday, while others are starting to wonder if it's really worth it. 

But really, it just comes down to whether or not cranberry sauce actually adds anything meaningful to the meal or just shows up purely out of habit. If cranberry sauce is something your family gravitates towards, then there's nothing wrong with including it—but don't feel like you have to serve it just because it's tradition.