That Decade Ate Different
The '90s had a lot going for it, and a lot going wrong, and the food situation was no exception to either. It was an era of bold artificial flavors, snacks engineered to look like nothing in nature, and a general willingness to experiment that the food industry seems to have quietly abandoned. Some things from that era deserved to die. But a whole lot of others got swept away with them, and we've been poorer for it ever since. Here's 20 foods from the '90s that genuinely deserve a second shot.
commons.wikimedia.org on Google
1. Jell-O Pudding Pops
These were different from regular Popsicles in a way that's hard to explain to someone who hasn't had one. The texture was denser, almost creamy in the middle, and the chocolate flavor actually tasted like something. Brands have tried to recreate them over the years, but the versions you can find now mostly miss the mark.
2. Surge
Surge came in like a truck and left a loyal fanbase bitter about its departure for decades. It made a brief comeback around 2014, but it never fully reclaimed shelf space the way it deserved. The citrus bite was sharper than Mountain Dew, and the neon green color felt genuinely transgressive in the best possible way.
3. Dunkaroos
Yes, they technically came back. No, they are not the same. The original ratio of cookie to frosting was calibrated by someone who understood joy, and the current formula doesn't quite hit it. Nostalgia packaging can only carry a product so far before the actual taste has to do the work.
:kirsch: from Raleigh, US on Wikimedia
4. Crystal Pepsi
Crystal Pepsi was weird, and that's exactly the point. The idea of a clear cola felt almost philosophical at the time, and the taste was clean in a way that regular Pepsi wasn't. It's the kind of product that could thrive today, when novelty and visual appeal drive so much of what gets shared and sold.
Mike Mozart from Funny YouTube, USA on Wikimedia
5. Oreo O's Cereal
This was not a subtle cereal, and it wasn't trying to be. Oreo O's were aggressively sweet in a way that made breakfast feel like a small rebellion. The version that briefly returned a few years back had a slightly different recipe, and cereal purists noticed immediately.
6. Waffle Crisp
Waffle Crisp was the rare breakfast cereal that actually tasted like what it claimed to be. The maple-butter flavor came through without being cloying, and the texture held up in milk better than most of its competitors. It disappeared quietly, and people are still asking where it went.
SomeBodyAnyBody05 on Wikimedia
7. 3D Doritos
Regular Doritos are good. 3D Doritos were a different experience entirely. The puffed shape created air pockets that changed the crunch and softened the edges just enough. Frito-Lay brought them back around 2020 in limited varieties, but the original lineup deserves a full return.
8. Hi-C Ecto Cooler
Ecto Cooler was orange-flavored juice drink with a greenish tint, and it was inexplicably delicious. It kept getting released in limited runs whenever a new Ghostbusters film came out, which suggests someone at Hi-C knows what they have. A permanent version shouldn't require a movie release as its justification.
9. Planters Cheez Balls
Planters brought these back for a limited run in 2018, and they sold out almost instantly. That should be enough evidence that the demand is real and consistent. The canister format felt different from a bag, and the balls themselves had a lighter, airier texture than most cheese snacks on the market now.
commons.wikimedia.org on Google
10. Squeezit
Squeezits were small plastic bottles of fruit-flavored drink that you squeezed directly into your mouth, and the fact that this product no longer exists is a minor tragedy. The flavors were bright and artificial in a way that felt intentional, and the packaging was designed for kids in a way that actually respected how kids wanted to drink things.
11. French Toast Crunch
French Toast Crunch was its own thing, distinct enough from Cinnamon Toast Crunch that losing it actually mattered. The maple-forward flavor was softer and warmer, and the tiny toast shape was weirdly satisfying. It returned briefly in Canada and eventually came back to the U.S., but availability has stayed inconsistent.
commons.wikimedia.org on Google
12. PB Crisps
Planters PB Crisps were peanut-shaped crackers with a peanut butter filling, and they hit a savory-sweet spot that almost nothing else on the market has since matched. They weren't chips, they weren't cookies, and they weren't candy. That ambiguity might be why they disappeared, but it's also exactly why they'd sell today.
13. Shark Bites Fruit Snacks
The white shark was the rare piece that everyone fought over, and Betty Crocker removed it sometime in the late '90s, which still generates genuine frustration from people who were there. The gummies themselves had a slightly firmer texture than the competition, and the flavor variety was solid. Bring back the white shark.
14. Hershey's Swoops
Swoops were thin, curved chocolate pieces shaped like Pringles, which sounds chaotic but worked beautifully. They came in flavors like Reese's and York Peppermint Patty, and the thin format meant you got concentrated flavor without the weight of a full candy bar. They were ahead of their time in terms of portion design.
15. Hubba Bubba Soda
This was exactly what it sounds like, and it was somehow great. A bubblegum-flavored soda shouldn't work as well as it did, but Hubba Bubba Soda had a sweetness that felt cheerful rather than cloying. It would be an enormous hit in an era where novelty beverages are their own cultural category.
Unknown authorUnknown author on Wikimedia
16. Pepsi Blue
Pepsi Blue was electric blue and tasted like berry-flavored candy, and it lasted less than two years before being discontinued in 2004. It came back internationally in 2021, which means someone at PepsiCo knows the formula is sitting in a drawer somewhere. American audiences deserve another chance with it.
17. Taco Bell's Mexican Pizza
Okay, this one technically returned after a massive public campaign, and then Taco Bell removed it again, and then it came back again in 2023. But the point stands: this item has proven multiple times that people want it, and it deserves a permanent, undisputed place on the menu.
18. McDonald's McSalad Shakers
These were salads served in a cup that you shook to distribute the dressing, which sounds gimmicky but was actually more practical than a flat bowl you're trying to eat in a car. The concept was ahead of its time, and the container design was genuinely clever. The execution just needed a better era.
19. Hostess Choco Bliss
Choco Bliss didn't get nearly the attention that Twinkies and Ho Hos received, which is probably why it disappeared without much fanfare. It was a chocolate cake with chocolate filling, denser than most Hostess products, and it leaned into the chocolate flavor in a way the brand didn't always commit to. It deserved better.
bader photographer on Unsplash
20. Crispy M&M's
Crispy M&M's had a devoted following and were discontinued in the U.S. in 2005, which sparked years of petitions. They did eventually return in 2015, but the rollout was quiet and the availability has never been reliable enough. For a product with this level of documented demand, the distribution should be a lot easier to find.
KEEP ON READING
The 5 Most Consumed Foods in the Entire World
.jpg){kind=link}
