×

The 10 Most Overrated Pizza Styles In The World & The 10 Best


The 10 Most Overrated Pizza Styles In The World & The 10 Best


Which Pizza Styles Are Worth Traveling For?

Pizza, being a simple food of essentially dough and toppings, lends itself well to creativity and endless riffs. Humans have been coming up with new styles of the dish since it was first invented in Naples; however, not all pies are created equal. While some leave you wondering what all the fuss is about, others slap every time, earning their classic status with every bite. Here are 10 of the most overrated pizza styles and 10 we will forever adore.

File:New York Pizza 08.jpgК.Артём.1 on Wikimedia


1. New York-Style

New York-style pizza is characterized by its large size and foldable crust, but not much else. It was developed with inexpensive one-handed eating in mind, more so than exceptional flavor.

sliced pizza on white ceramic plateThe Nix Company on Unsplash

2. Rhode Island-Style 

Rhode Island-style pizza is unique for its rectangular shape and thick, focaccia-like dough and is typically served at room temperature. Sorry, Rhode Island, but this is essentially a soggy piece of bread.

File:Sicilian pizza at Fellini Pizzeria.jpgThe Pizza Review on Wikimedia

3. St. Louis-Style

As much as we love thin crust, St. Louis just took it too far. This style of pizza has no yeast in the dough, yielding a crust so thin and crispy, it's like you're eating a cracker.

File:St Louis Missouri pizza in cardboard box.jpgDale Cruse on Wikimedia

Advertisement

4. Greek Pizza

Greek pizza isn't just pizza with olives and feta cheese; it's characterized by its pan-fried crust. The idea is to yield a super crispy, caramelized crust, but it generally results in a pizza far too drenched in oil.

File:Greek pizza.jpgkatharine j moriarty on Wikimedia

5. Philadelphia Tomato Pie

Philadelphia tomato pie is definitely more like a focaccia than a pizza. It's extremely bready with a disproportionate sauce-to-base ratio. Just like in Rhode Island, this pizza is puzzlingly served at room temperature or even cold.

Anna GuerreroAnna Guerrero on Pexels

6. Sicilian-Style

Like the Philadelphia-style pizza, Sicilian pizza is special because of its thick, focaccia-like crust, resulting in a spongy base. The bread gets topped with cheese and then sauce on top, which is perplexing and just seems wrong.

File:L&B Spumoni Gardens pizza (41436).jpgRhododendrites on Wikimedia

7. Buffalo-Style 

Buffalo-style pizza has a substantial, bready crust and tends to be cut into rectangular pieces. It's not foldable like NY-style pizza and isn't as thick as Sicilian-style; it's in the awkward middle ground, lacks balance and flavor, and comes overly greasy. 

A pizza sitting on top of a wooden tableGina's Auckland on Unsplash

8. California-Style

California-style pizza isn't notable for its crust, but its toppings, which usually consist of lean protein and something green. The fact that its toppings are so healthy takes all the fun out of pizza.

File:California club pizza.jpgShane Adams from Olathe, KS, USA on Wikimedia

9. Dessert Pizza

We are unsure why pizza chains continue to put Nutella on pizza dough and try to pass it off as a worthy dessert. It's almost always too extra and makes for a poor pairing. 

pedro furtadopedro furtado on Pexels

Advertisement

10. Miami-Style

Miami-style, also sometimes called Cuban-style pizza, is thick-crust pizza topped with a very thin layer of sauce and an extremely heavy dumping of cheese. The dough is commonly undercooked, and the cheese makes it far too greasy. 

Cheese bread is served on a wooden board.Rodrigo Rodrigues | WOLF Λ R T on Unsplash

Now that we've covered some of the most overrated pizza styles, let's talk about our most beloved ones. 

1. Neapolitan 

Neapolitan-style pizza is the king of all pizzas. Not only is it the OG, but it's clearly the best, with centuries of refinement under its belt. Long-fermented dough is topped with a few simple ingredients and baked in a wood-fired oven to create this perfect pie, celebrated for its freshness and simplicity.

pizza on brown wooden tableNik Owens on Unsplash

2. Detroit-Style

Detroit-style pizza is famous for its delightfully caramelized edges achieved by baking in signature rectangular pans originally used for automotive parts. It's light and fluffy on the inside and crispy on the outside with ingredients geniusly layered under the cheese to prevent the crust from getting soggy.

File:Detroit-Style Pizza-Slice.jpgRenewableandalternativeenergy on Wikimedia

3. Chicago Deep-Dish

Chicago deep-dish pizza is arguably the most innovative of all pizza forms. Its crust is like a pie dough that's filled with delicious tomato sauce and toppings layered in. 

File:Chicago-style pizza.jpgL. W. Yang on Wikimedia

4. Roman-Style

Roman-style pizza is a distinct Italian-style pizza characterized by its thin crust and oblong shape. It was developed as a street food more fit for takeaway than Neapolitan pizza, which is commonly eaten with a fork and knife.

ENESFİLMENESFİLM on Pexels

5. New Haven-Style Apizza

New Haven-style "apizza," so-called because of the way Neapolitan immigrants would pronounce "pizza," is distinct for its minimalist toppings and smoky char from the gas-fired or coal-fired ovens. We love the uniqueness and simplicity of this style of pie.

File:Apizza.jpgSallysapizza on Wikimedia

Advertisement

6. Calabrian-Style

Calabrian-style pizza from Calabria, southern Italy, is similar to Neapolitan, but the toppings are bolder and crazier, which we're all for. The crust is also a little thicker than Neapolitan but still light, striking a perfect balance.

Federica GioiaFederica Gioia on Pexels

7. Grandma Pie

Grandma pie is the kind of pizza you could make at home. Its crust is thin and slightly chewy, baked in a rectangular pan instead of directly on the hearth. It's unfussy, rustic, comforting, and delicious. 

File:Grandma Pizza.jpgVillageSquarePizza on Wikimedia

8. Montreal-Style

Montreal-style pizza is characterized by its thicker crust that still manages to remain crispy, herby tomato sauce. It's topped with a creative mix of local ingredients and abundant cheese, and manages to capture the ethnic diversity of the city itself. 

File:Pointe de pizza.jpgJeangagnon on Wikimedia

9. Chicago Tavern Style

Chicago knows how to do pizza; the city boasts not one but two successful styles. The tavern style has a crust that is much thinner than average, but unlike St. Louis-style dough, it still contains yeast, so it has much more flavor.

File:Croccante Pizza - November 2023 - Sarah Stierch 02.jpgMissvain on Wikimedia

10. Argentinian Fugazzeta

Easily one of the best and most creative riffs on pizza in the world, Argentinian fugazzeta is made up of a stuffed double crust with cheese and toppings layered between. It's like if lasagna and pizza had a beautiful baby.

File:Fugazzeta en pizzeria Guerrin, Buenos Aires.JPGAleposta on Wikimedia