Southern Desserts Play By Their Own Rules
The American South has never needed anyone else's approval where dessert’s concerned—and it’s a good thing, too. Head into Arkansas, Louisiana, Kentucky, or the Carolinas and you'll encounter everything from a pie named after a possum to cakes made with bakery scraps. Whatever delicacy it is, we can bet our boots that Northerners are missing out, and that’s why we’re here to break down the best 20 dishes.
1. Arkansas Possum Pie
Relax, everyone! There isn't any actual possum hiding in the whipped topping. Instead, possum pie piles cream cheese, chocolate pudding, whipped cream, and pecans onto a nutty crust. Its deceptive appearance is really what inspired the name.
2. North Carolina Sonker
Travel around Surry County, North Carolina, and you’ll definitely encounter sonker, a fruit dessert that’s a far cry from your everyday cobblers. Recipes contain blackberries, peaches, cherries, apples, or sweet potatoes beneath a pastry or dough topping, and some families serve it with a sweet milk-based "dip."
3. Kentucky Transparent Pie
Say what you will about the name, but its cloudy golden filling isn't actually transparent at all. The filling relies on eggs, sugar, butter, and cream to give you an intensely sweet custard in a pastry shell. It’s a lot better than it originally sounds!
4. Florida Sour Orange Pie
Before Key lime pie became Florida's celebrity dessert, sour oranges provided another option for citrus-loving locals. Sour orange pie uses the sharp juice of bitter oranges in a creamy filling, giving it more bite than many you’d expect. However, though it’s sharper, that doesn’t mean it’s worse than the traditional stuff you spot in stores!
5. New Orleans Doberge Cake
You can forget Northern modesty with these honkin’ slices. This local specialty stacks thin cake layers with pudding or custard, then covers everything with frosting. Yes, it’s as good as it sounds, especially with chocolate and lemon among the classic flavors!
6. Louisiana Calas
Long before doughnuts dominated breakfast, New Orleans had calas, which are nothing more than fried sweets made with cooked rice. Don’t knock it ‘til you try it, though! The rice is mixed into a batter, fried until browned, and dusted generously with powdered sugar, creating a treat with a history deeply tied to the city's Creole food culture.
7. Louisiana Tarte À La Bouillie
Cajun country does a lot more than fried chicken; tarte à la bouillie gives you just about everything you could ask for in a dessert. It’s filled with a cooked sweet custard, often flavored simply with vanilla, inside a homemade crust. It isn't flashy, but that old-fashioned filling is an easy sell.
8. Charleston Benne Wafers
Charleston's benne wafers are thin, they’re crisp, and they’re packed with sesame seeds. They're usually made with brown sugar, butter, and plenty of toasted benne seeds, so the flavor is nuttier and more savory than a typical sugar cookie—but that’s a good thing. Why stick to chocolate chips when you have so many other options on the table?
9. Charleston Huguenot Torte
Despite the name, Charleston's Huguenot torte is a sticky baked dessert centered on apples and nuts, not a delicate pastry. It quickly became a specialty, though, and it’s commonly baked until the sugary top becomes crisp while the fruit underneath remains soft.
10. Charleston Lady Baltimore Cake
Lady Baltimore cake became closely connected with Charleston, and just about any local would tell you why: it’s one of the city's more old-fashioned sweets! Traditional versions sandwich white cake with a fluffy icing and a filling containing ingredients such as raisins, figs, and nuts, creating more on the inside than the exterior suggests.
11. Winston-Salem Moravian Sugar Cake
North Carolina's Moravian baking tradition gave Winston-Salem a cake that isn't really shaped or textured the way you’d expect. Moravian sugar cake is actually a yeast-raised creation covered with butter, brown sugar, and cinnamon. The whole thing leaves you with a rich surface filled with indentations after baking. It might look weird, but its taste is anything but.
12. North Carolina Moravian Spice Cookies
Sorry, we’re not done with unique cookies yet! This Winston-Salem specialty takes the opposite approach to the enormous cookies found in your fancy Northern bakeries. Moravian spice cookies are rolled thin and flavored with molasses and warm spices. What you’re left with is a crisp snap instead of a chewy center.
13. Kentucky Jam Cake
Jam in a cake? Count us in! This one takes the cake—literally—by adding a generous amount of jam directly to the batter. Nuts, raisins, warm spices, and caramel-style icing can join the party, leaving each slice unusually dark, dense, and heavily flavored.
14. Appalachian Apple Stack Cake
Sheet cakes are all well and good, but real Southerners know the best bite is in a stack cake. Rather than being eaten immediately, this one actually benefits from sitting long enough for that apple filling to soften the layers. It’s not called going soggy—it’s called waiting for the best part!
thebittenword.com on Wikimedia
15. Virginia Peanut Pie
Virginia peanut country naturally found a way to put roasted peanuts into an actual pie, and we couldn’t be more grateful. The nuts sit in a sugary filling made with ingredients such as eggs, syrup, butter, and brown sugar, which creates its distinctly salty-sweet character. You bet we’re going back for seconds.
16. Appalachian Vinegar Pie
Fruit wasn’t always readily available, which is exactly how vinegar pie was born. We know it sounds odd, but it’s tastier than it seems. That small amount of vinegar is what gives the sugary egg-and-butter filling enough acidity to keep the pie from being unbearably sweet.
17. Southern Butter Rolls
Butter rolls are one of those deeply old-school desserts that don't spend much time on presentation. And why would they? All you need to do is roll pieces of dough with butter and sugar before baking everything in a sweet, milky sauce. Then you can sink your teeth into something soft and thoroughly saturated.
18. New Orleans Russian Cake
When it comes to this cake, you’re in for a real treat! Traditional versions repurpose pieces of leftover cake and pastry, binding them together with ingredients like jam and rum before covering the whole thing in frosting. Don’t ever say New Orleans never taught you anything.
19. New Orleans Huckabuck
We know it seems like it, but during a Louisiana summer, frozen treats don’t need to be fancy. Huckabucks are old-fashioned frozen desserts made from sweetened flavored liquid, usually frozen in small cups and eaten as they begin to soften. Plenty of New Orleans childhoods wouldn't have been the same without one.
20. Southern Sweet Potato Pone
Sweet potato can do a lot more than wow at a Thanksgiving table. Southern versions combine them either grated or mashed with sugar, butter, milk, and spices before baking the mixture into a dense dessert. Think of it like a mix between pudding and cake in texture.
KEEP ON READING
You’re Storing Tomatoes Wrong in This Heat
You’re Storing Potatoes Wrong in This Heat
You’re Storing Peppers Wrong in This Heat
You’re Storing Carrots Wrong in This Heat
