Cheesy Delight Or Cheap Cardboard?
Sometimes, frozen pizza feels like that reliable buddy who shows up late but still brings the party when you need it most. Other times, it’s more like the friend who forgets your birthday and follows up with a half-hearted “happy belated.” If you’re aiming for something more reliable, don’t just toss any frozen pie into your cart. Let’s talk about which frozen pizzas actually earn a spot in your freezer and which ones to skip altogether.
Red Baron Classic Crust Four Cheese Pizza Review! by TheReportOfTheWeek
1. Newman’s Own
Craving a frozen pizza that tastes way better than it should? Newman’s Own nails it with a multigrain crust that crisps up just right, a herbed sauce packed with Italian flavor, and a cheese pull that stretches deliciously. Every time you pop one in the oven, it feels like homemade love.
Newman’s Own Thin & Crispy Crust Four Cheese Pizza Review by Tami Dunn
2. Red Baron
Picture the first bite, which starts as a crunchy yet tender crust snapping under your teeth. Next comes the flavor-packed tomato sauce, which sings on your tongue, and finally, a velvety layer of molten cheese. Red Baron crafts pizzas that refuse to taste like they were made from frozen dough.
3. DiGiorno
The towering crust of DiGiorno pizzas puffs up to offer a hearty chew. Enthusiasts prize it for bringing that pizzeria-yeast aroma into your kitchen, even if the cheese occasionally goes rogue. Don’t miss stocking it for a lazy (or busy) pizza night.
DiGiorno Crispy Pan Pizza | Pepperoni | Can She Make it? by The Project Help Desk
4. Home Run Inn
Home Run Inn vaults from Chicago’s tradition to offer pizzas built on buttery thin crusts and topped with real mozzarella. When you get this frozen pizza brand, you’ll feel like royalty as each bite rewards your patience with a richness that mass-market competitors struggle to replicate.
Barstool Pizza Review - Home Run Inn Frozen Pizza by One Bite Pizza Reviews
5. California Pizza Kitchen
Ever wanted a restaurant date in your pajamas? Well, California Pizza Kitchen’s frozen options brag about having daring toppings like BBQ chicken and white truffle that fit the bill. Here, expect a gourmet experience bursting from their thin, delicate crust.
California Pizza Kitchen: Four Cheese Pizza Review by Tami Dunn
6. Screamin’ Sicilian
For those who believe “more is more,” Screamin’ Sicilian satisfies with aggressive heaps of pepperoni and savory tomato sauce. Each mouthful bursts with audacious flavor, urging you to abandon restraint. Dive fork-first into their zany packaging since what’s inside screams louder than the box.
Barstool Pizza Review - Screamin' Sicilian Frozen Pizza by One Bite Pizza Reviews
7. Milton’s Craft Bakers
Health-conscious foodies rally around Milton’s, where cauliflower crust transforms from a dreaded afterthought to a beloved foundation. Gluten-free yet never joy-free, their pies charm without compromise. Bite into wholesome goodness and reimagine what “healthy frozen pizza” actually tastes like.
Milton's Craft Bakers Roasted Vegetable Cauliflower Crust by The Pizza Diaries
8. Freschetta
Busy weeknights call for the steady hand of Freschetta. The best part? They offer a range of options, from the rising crusts to the thin offerings and brick-oven styles. Their harmonious layering of ingredients also saves you from flavor fatigue.
🍕 Freschetta Five Cheese Brick Oven Crust - Frozen Pizza Review by The Tiny Reviewer
9. Amy’s Kitchen
Amy’s Kitchen crafts organic delights that emphasize vegetarian choices without sacrificing satisfaction. The highlight has to be their pesto-topped marvels, which sing with earthy vibrance. Some crusts may be softer than expected, but with quality ingredients shining through, Amy’s remains at the top.
Barstool Pizza Review - Amy's Frozen Pizza by One Bite Pizza Reviews
10. Trader Joe’s
Ah, Trader Joe’s! The renegade of frozen aisles, where toppings like burrata and arugula surprise you at every turn. One pizza might wow; another might flop—but where’s the adventure without risk? This brand is perfect for spontaneous culinary thrill seekers!
🍕Organic Roasted Vegetable Pizza (Ep. #104) - Trader Joe’s Product Review by The Tiny Reviewer
For every slice of greatness, there’s one that leaves you wondering why you even bothered. Now that the champions have had their moment, let’s dive into the 10 worst frozen pizza brands you’ll want to steer clear of.
1. Totino’s
Remember cardboard art projects from elementary school? Totino’s thin, dry crusts sadly recall that very texture. This brand’s overly sweet sauce and skimpy toppings betray even the most forgiving of palates. Save yourself the heartbreak; your taste buds deserve better.
Totinos Party Pizza Review Mukbang by hoohoohoblin
2. Celeste
Celeste pizzas promise “Abbondanza” but deliver mediocrity. The cheese melts into puddles; the crust stays suspiciously soggy, and flavor flickers instead of flames. Avoid it unless you’re hosting a “worst-tasting party” because that’s the only time it becomes comedic gold.
Barstool Pizza Review - Mama Celeste Frozen Pizza by One Bite Pizza Reviews
3. Kroger Store Brand
First, the dough tastes undercooked even after extra minutes. Then, the cheese turns plastic-like once it has cooled, and the toppings vanish into oblivion. For these reasons, when your eyes read anything Kro… in the frozen pizza aisle, run!
4. Kirkland Signature (Costco)
Costco’s in-house brand, Kirkland Signature, offers a variety of products, but its frozen pizzas have received mixed reviews. Some customers find the crust to be overly thick and doughy, while others claim the cheese and toppings can be inconsistent in quality and distribution.
Costco Kirkland Signature Pepperoni Frozen Pizza Review by PapiEats
5. Ellio’s
Unless you’re craving memories from a ’90s after-school snack gone wrong, steer clear. Straight out of a nostalgia time machine, Ellio’s keeps calories hidden beneath fluorescent cheese. One bite reveals their rubbery crust and alarming saltiness that will make you flinch.
Ellio's Pizza: The History Behind Its Unconventional Shape by Pop Culture Chronicles
6. Simple Truth Organic
Simple Truth’s frozen pizzas remind you that organic does not guarantee deliciousness. Odd pairings like goat cheese and fig easily overwhelm instead of impress. While health claims dazzle, remember that flavor must come first; otherwise, the party falls flat.
7. Caulipower
When cauliflower crusts first took off, expectations were low. Then, Caulipower confirms why. Their crusts crumble beneath toppings, robbing you of satisfaction. Better save cauliflower for stews, mash, or rice, not your Friday pizza plans.
Caulipower Half Cheese Half Pepperoni Pizza Frozen Food Review by Cindys Home Kitchen
8. Tony’s
Tony’s has been a staple in the frozen pizza aisle for decades, but longevity doesn’t always equate to quality. Many consumers have criticized its sauce for being watery and lacking flavor. The cheese and toppings are sparse, leading to an overall unsatisfying experience.
TONY'S Pepperoni Pizza by casualgamerreed
9. Whole Foods 365
Despite Whole Foods’ reputation, its 365 frozen pizzas have disappointed many. Common complaints include a bland, pasty sauce and a crust that lacks both texture and flavor. Then, enter the minimal toppings that fail to justify the price point.
365 Whole Foods Market Frozen Thin Crust Four Cheese Pizza by Stuck-at-Home Cooking
10. Banza
Banza’s attempt to reinvent the wheel via chickpea crust skids off course. Heavy and oddly earthy, their pizzas often clash with traditional sauces and cheeses. Sadly, good intentions can’t mask poor execution. So, let your taste buds dodge this frozen pothole.
