Navigating the Best and Worst of the Big Apple
Eating your way through New York City is a high-stakes adventure where you can find world-class cuisine on one block and a total tourist trap on the next. With thousands of options tucked into every corner of the five boroughs, it’s easy to get overwhelmed by flashy neon signs or glowing reviews that don’t always tell the whole story. You’ll want to steer clear of the spots that rely on their location rather than their ingredients while making sure you save room for the legendary institutions that actually live up to the hype.
1. Times Square Pizza Chains
Sure, there will be neon lights and signs you recognize, but these overpriced tourist traps are almost always the worst place to get pizza in NYC. They know you’re tired and hungry and will try to trick you into buying a rubbery, cold slice for $5. Just walk a few blocks in either direction until you find a literal hole in the wall.
2. Bubba Gump Shrimp Co.
While the film may be beloved, the restaurant itself is basically a tourist Michelin star among restaurant enthusiasts and travelers everywhere. You’ll pay top dollar for your seat with a view of other tourists, but your shrimp will taste like it was pulled from a frozen bag at the grocery store. Go ahead and grab a souvenir glass.
3. Guy’s American Kitchen & Bar (Historical Mention)
Even though this spot has since closed its doors, it remains a legendary example of a celebrity-owned restaurant that critics absolutely tore apart for its messy menu. The food was often described as a confusing explosion of sauces and deep-fried everything that lacked any real balance or culinary finesse. It serves as a permanent warning to travelers that a famous face on the sign doesn't always mean there’s a talented chef in the back.
4. Overpriced Hotel Breakfasts
Did you really spend $300+ on a hotel room just so you can eat an overpriced plate of eggs? Get yourself off the comfy bed and walk two feet outside to find a million options that will taste better than your carpeted cafeteria. NYC is the breakfast sandwich capital of the world, so skip the fine china and find a local deli that serves a masterpiece on a roll for a quarter of the price.
5. Eleven Madison Park (Post-Vegan Shift)
Can a restaurant go too vegan? According to fans of the restaurant before its massive menu change, yes. While some adore EMP’s new purpose, critics of the pricey spot are not shy with their complaints. Diners felt the creativity went downhill quickly after going plant-based, while prices stayed the same.
6. The "Scam" Comedy Club Dinners
If you're pulled off the street with a "free ticket" to a show, be prepared for a mandatory two-item minimum that features some of the most lackluster food in the city. You’ll likely be served lukewarm chicken fingers or a watered-down cocktail that costs more than a full meal at a decent restaurant. It’s a classic trap that turns a fun night of laughs into a frustrating realization that you've overpaid for bar snacks.
7. Jekyll & Hyde Club
This animatronic lobster rock-show is great for kids but falls flat when it comes to the adult dining experience. Between struggling to hear each other over explosions and sluggish service, the food is mediocre at best. The burgers aren’t the best either.
Saundarya Srinivasan on Unsplash
8. Serendipity 3 (For Main Courses)
Everyone goes here for the famous Frrrozen Hot Chocolate, which is genuinely fun, but staying for a full dinner is usually a mistake. The savory menu is often overshadowed by the dessert craze, leaving you with average café food at prices that feel a bit inflated for the quality. If you really want the sugar rush, just stop in for a treat and find your actual dinner at a nearby spot that focuses more on the entrée than the spectacle.
9. Any $1 Pizza With a Line
Sure, it may be cheap, but dollar pizza is practically extinct these days. If you see a slice displayed behind glass looking like something the DMV would accept as an ID photo, move along. Those slices used to be legit, but you’re better off paying three bucks more at this point.
10. Bella Blu
Italian eateries are ten a penny in NYC. And while this Upper East Side spot has wonderful food, it isn’t worth the attitude some servers give to unsuspecting tourists. There are so many welcoming, family-run Italian joints in the city that it feels unnecessary to put up with a chilly vibe for a basic dinner.
Now that we’ve talked about some of the less-than-wonderful restaurants in New York, here are 10 fantastic ones.
1. Joe’s Pizza
Joe’s is where you get your slice of New York pizza heaven. The crust is paper thin and foldable just the right amount. You’ll find the perfect ratio of tangy tomato sauce to salty mozzarella cheese, which other slices try to mimic for generations to come.
2. Los Tacos No. 1
Hidden inside Chelsea Market and a couple of other locations, this taco stand is serving up what are arguably the best tacos on the East Coast. Grab yourself an adobada on a flour tortilla and don’t skip the salsa bar at the end. It’s cash-only, stand-up dining at its finest.
3. Le Bernardin
If you’re looking to splurge on a world-class seafood experience, Eric Ripert’s legendary establishment is the place where dreams come true. The service is impeccably polished without feeling stuffy, and every single dish is a masterpiece of technique and fresh ingredients. It has maintained its three Michelin stars for a reason, and you'll leave feeling like you’ve experienced the absolute pinnacle of fine dining.
4. Katz's Delicatessen
Sure, it was featured in When Harry Met Sally, but there’s a reason pastrami sandwiches towering high from this Jewish deli have been hailed as some of the best in the city. The ordering system is hectic with those red tickets, but it’s worth the wait. Sink your teeth into their super juicy, perfectly smoked meat that’s carved right in front of you.
5. Adda Indian Canteen
Adda specializes in Indian cuisine that they describe as “unapologetic.” What that means is they aren’t holding back on flavor or spirit to make their food more accessible. Their goat biryani is a dish talked about on a near-mythical level, so you’ve got to try it for yourself.
6. Bleecker Street Pizza
This West Village pizza joint is great for when you’re craving that New York slice, but with a slightly higher-end touch. Their pizza named “Nonna Maria” comes topped with fresh mozzarella and award-winning secret sauce. Stop by and grab a slice to go.
7. Atomix
Expect to learn a thing or two when you dine at Atomix. Not only will you be enjoying one of the best meals you’ll have in your life, but also getting a history lesson along the way. Every dish that makes up their progressive Korean tasting menu comes with a small card detailing where they sourced the ingredient from and its cultural relevance.
8. L&B Spumoni Gardens
You’ll have to head out to Brooklyn for this one, but the thick, square Sicilian slices are absolutely worth the subway ride. The unique way they layer the cheese under the sweet tomato sauce creates a texture that is soft, chewy, and entirely addictive. Make sure you finish your meal with a scoop of their famous tri-color spumoni ice cream for the ultimate old-school Brooklyn experience.
9. Theodora
If you’re in the Market District, stop by Theodora and check out some of the best fish you’ll find. The whole restaurant revolves around live-fire cooking, and you’ll immediately smell the charcoal grilling as you walk in the door. The fish they serve is incredibly fresh and dry-aged before it’s cooked to perfection.
10. Gray's Papaya
For the ultimate budget-friendly New York experience, you can't beat the "Recession Special" at this Upper West Side hot dog stand. You'll get two perfectly snapped franks and a tropical fruit drink for a price that feels like a total steal in such an expensive city. It’s a no-frills, standing-room-only classic that has fed everyone from starving students to famous celebrities for decades.
KEEP ON READING
