Spooky Season Deserves Better
Halloween parties are supposed to be fun, so why do these spooky gatherings bring the most lackluster dishes to the table? Amid all those costumes and homemade drinks, not everyone understands the assignment, and some guests arrive with plates better suited for an ordinary potluck. Well, no more! From uninspired casseroles to disappointing desserts, here are 20 dishes that leave partygoers wishing for more.
1. Candy Corn Snack Mix
Every Halloween party seems to have someone who empties a bag of candy corn into a bowl of pretzels for a “festive snack mix.” We hate to break it to you, but that combo doesn't offer much excitement when guests can buy the same stuff at any store. That’s not to say you can’t spice it up, though! Adding chocolate-covered peanuts, caramel popcorn, or homemade spiced nuts would at least make it more thoughtful.
2. Turkey Sandwiches
There's nothing festive about white bread stuffed with deli turkey and a slice of cheese. Sure, these sandwiches are perfectly acceptable for lunch, but they're a disappointing contribution when everyone else was in the mood for Halloween appetizers. At least adding cranberry spread or toasted rolls would be worth getting excited about.
David Foodphototasty on Unsplash
3. Plain Rice Krispies Treats
You'd think Halloween would be the perfect opportunity to get creative with Rice Krispies treats, but some people don't bother. We're talking about ordinary squares made with marshmallows and cereal, not a single sprinkle in sight. Considering how easily you can turn them into little pumpkins or chocolate-covered monsters, showing up with the basic version is pretty uninspired.
4. Undressed Coleslaw
A giant container of shredded cabbage and carrots? No witch or mummy will pick at that! Without a flavorful dressing, this crunchy side dish offers little excitement, especially when surrounded by more indulgent snacks. Even a homemade apple cider vinaigrette would make the veggies feel more appropriate for an October gathering.
5. Deviled Eggs
Deviled eggs are a potluck tradition, and we’re not saying they don’t hold a special place in our hearts. But the standard version topped with paprika isn't exciting anymore. Halloween gives you plenty of opportunities to decorate them with olive spiders or turn the fillings green for a slightly creepy appearance. Without those little touches, they're just the same appetizers your relatives bring to Easter dinner.
6. Roasted Pumpkin Seeds
Hey, this is spooky season, and that means pumpkin all around! That doesn’t mean every version deserves a place on the party table, though. Some people simply scoop out their pumpkins, roast the seeds without seasoning, and leave them in a bowl. If you actually want people to eat them, add a little cinnamon sugar, smoked paprika, or garlic salt.
7. Baked Potatoes
Imagine arriving at a Halloween party only to find out that dinner is foil-wrapped potatoes. Baked potatoes are fine—when you dress them up a little! Without sour cream, bacon bits, shredded cheese, or even chopped chives, there's very little to enjoy beyond the potato itself.
8. Vanilla Cupcakes
Vanilla cupcakes hit our sweet tooth almost every time, but the grocery store variety with a tiny swirl of frosting doesn't feel very special. Halloween allows you to jazz up those pastries with orange frosting, chocolate spiders, and candy decorations that take only minutes to prepare.
9. Store-Bought Halloween Sugar Cookies
Speaking of the grocery store, you've probably seen those premade sugar cookies with pumpkins or ghosts printed in the centers. Although they're nostalgic (and polarizing), bringing a plate of them straight from the oven doesn't require much creativity. You can easily make them your own with a little homemade frosting or a chocolate drizzle.
10. Popcorn Bags
Popcorn makes sense at Halloween, and everyone will love you on a movie night! However, handing out little paper bags filled with ordinary salted popcorn isn't exactly a memorable contribution. If you really want to make wolves howl, caramel coating, melted chocolate, or a sprinkle of cinnamon sugar would give guests something more exciting to munch on.
11. Pigs in a Blanket
Pigs in a blanket are a potluck staple. Who among us would turn down cocktail sausages wrapped in crescent dough? The thing is, they're hardly surprising when you've eaten the same appetizer at every event since childhood. Serving them with homemade honey mustard or spicy dipping sauce makes this familiar snack a little more appealing.
Ann Larie Valentine on Wikimedia
12. Buttered Egg Noodles
Buttered egg noodles might remind you of comforting childhood dinners, but they're hardly an exciting addition to a Halloween potluck. A casserole dish filled with plain noodles and melted butter offers little flavor compared to the hearty appetizers and seasonal recipes surrounding it. Save this family favorite for an ordinary dinner and bring something with more personality.
13. Dinner Rolls
A basket of store-bought dinner rolls is useful when you're hosting Thanksgiving, but they don’t really have any place at Halloween parties. Unless there's a substantial meal that requires bread, guests aren't going to reach for an ordinary roll when other snacks are available. If you’re in a pinch, at least add some garlic butter, melted cheese, or a savory filling!
14. Clementine Pumpkins
Someone always seems to bring a platter of peeled clementines with little pieces of celery sticking out of the tops. They’re cute, don’t get us wrong, but this Halloween snack has become so familiar that it rarely inspires enthusiasm. Fresh fruit is certainly appreciated, though, so a festive fruit dip or a more creative arrangement would make the platter more inviting.
Mehmet Turgut Kirkgoz on Pexels
15. Baked Ziti
Baked ziti is a reliable dinner—not a tried-and-true Halloween dish. Once it cools down on the table, those noodles get even less appealing to guests who'd rather enjoy something freshly prepared. If you're committed to bringing pasta, generous amounts of mozzarella, ricotta, and flavorful tomato sauce all make a considerable difference.
16. Oatmeal Cookies
Far be it from us to complain about oatmeal cookies. They deserve more love than they get! Still, a plate of dry, undecorated cookies can seem rather ordinary at a celebration known for its creativity. Adding chocolate chunks, cinnamon frosting, or a pumpkin spice filling would give this beloved treat a much-needed seasonal upgrade.
17. Steamed Broccoli With Lemon
Contrary to popular belief, veggies are always welcome at gatherings. That said, there's a difference between offering something nutritious and bringing an uninspired side. A container of steamed broccoli and a squeeze of lemon juice won’t go over well, so try roasting the florets with garlic and crispy breadcrumbs first!
Tyrrell Fitness And Nutrition on Unsplash
18. Pretzel Rod Ghosts
Dipping pretzels in white chocolate and adding candy eyes is one of the easiest Halloween treats imaginable. Unfortunately, these little ghosts have appeared at so many parties that they're predictable. That’s why using flavored chocolate, colorful sprinkles, or crushed cookies gives this old-fashioned snack the update it deserves!
19. Banana Bread
Homemade banana bread has its fans (us included), but a plain loaf at the table? That isn't necessarily what people want to see at a Halloween party. Chocolate chips, a cinnamon crumble topping, or a pumpkin swirl would give this everyday favorite a more seasonal twist that gets more guests excited.
20. Marshmallow Ghosts
A plate of marshmallows decorated with chocolate chip eyes might look cute, but it isn't especially impressive! These little ghosts are incredibly easy to assemble, allowing you to add a few things along the way without much fuss. Try dipping them in chocolate or turning them into miniature s'mores instead.
KEEP ON READING
The Surprising History Of The American Breakfast
Why Your Fridge Door Is the Worst Place for Milk
10 Best Finds at Costco & 10 Worth Skipping
20 Foods That Have No Flavor
The 20 Worst Foods To Order For Delivery
