10 New York Foods Tourists Overrate & 10 Locals Actually Love
10 New York Foods Tourists Overrate & 10 Locals Actually Love
New York Food Goes Far Beyond the Tourist Checklist
New York is one of the best eating cities in the world, but that doesn’t mean everything with a long line deserves the hype. Tourists tend to arrive with a checklist of famous foods they’ve seen online, while locals are often eating something much simpler a few blocks away. Some iconic dishes are still worth trying, of course, but others have become more famous than they are satisfying. Here are 10 New York foods tourists tend to overrate, followed by 10 favorites that locals actually make part of their regular routines.
1. Giant Times Square Pizza Slices
A massive slice of pizza can look impressive in a photo, especially when it’s practically hanging off the paper plate. Unfortunately, size doesn’t necessarily mean you’re getting great quality. In New York, a smaller slice from a good neighborhood shop can be much more satisfying than in the tourist-heavy parts of Midtown.
2. Rainbow Bagels
Rainbow bagels became famous largely because they looked good on social media, not because New Yorkers decided their breakfast needed six different colors. They’re often sweeter and denser than the traditional version, especially when paired with sugary cream cheese. You’ll certainly remember eating one, but probably not because it was the best bagel you had in the city.
HeatherMarieKosur on Wikimedia
3. Overloaded Milkshakes
Giant milkshakes sure know how to draw a crowd in New York, but it's mostly for the photo op. Actually finishing a milkshake covered with cookies, candy, frosting, whipped cream, and an entire slice of cake is a feat in itself. These towering desserts became tourist attractions in their own right, but the toppings are quite simply overwhelming. Plenty of New Yorkers would rather have a straightforward scoop of good ice cream.
4. Foot-Tall Pastrami Sandwiches
New York pastrami absolutely deserves its reputation, but tourists sometimes assume the biggest sandwich must be the best one. Once you're dealing with a pile of meat several inches high, eating it becomes more of a logistical problem than a meal. A more reasonably portioned pastrami sandwich still gives you the smoky, peppery flavor without requiring a strategy to take the first bite.
5. Cronuts & Their Copycats
When the cronut first arrived, people famously lined up to get their hands on one. The pastry inspired countless imitators and helped launch a whole era of desserts designed to become viral sensations. A good one can still be delicious, but tourists sometimes treat it like mandatory New York eating. Locals aren't necessarily starting their mornings by hunting down a croissant-doughnut hybrid.
Juan Francisco Ortíz Carrillo on Pexels
6. Gold-Covered Food
New York restaurants have put edible gold on everything from doughnuts to pizza, usually with a price tag to match. The gold itself contributes very little to the actual flavor, which makes the experience mostly about saying you tried it. It may photograph well, but there are far tastier things you could spend that money on while you're in the city.
7. Instagram-Friendly Brunch Pancakes
Some New York brunch spots serve enormous pancake stacks decorated with fruit, sauces, whipped cream, and plenty of powdered sugar. They're visually impressive, but they can become heavy after only a few bites. Tourists may happily wait in a long line for them, but most locals would rather find a reliable neighborhood diner and be fed right away.
8. Novelty Doughnuts
New York bakeries have experimented with doughnuts topped with cereal, cookies, candy bars, and nearly every other dessert imaginable. Sometimes the results are great, but excessive toppings can turn a simple pastry into an overly sweet mess. A fresh glazed or jelly doughnut from a dependable bakery often doesn't need nearly as much decoration to taste good.
9. $20 Hot Dogs
Hot dogs are part of New York's food identity, which makes upscale versions surprisingly easy to sell. Once restaurants start adding premium toppings and charging restaurant-entree prices, though, much of the charm disappears. There's something strange about needing a knife and fork for a food that New Yorkers have traditionally eaten while standing on a sidewalk.
10. Cheesecake From Any Tourist Trap
New York cheesecake deserves to be famous, but not every slice sold near a major attraction is automatically exceptional. Some places rely on the city's reputation while serving thick, overly sweet pieces that could come from almost anywhere. If you're going to have cheesecake in New York, it's worth choosing a bakery or restaurant known for making it well rather than simply ordering the nearest slice.
Now that we've covered the New York foods that are mostly just for tourists, let's talk about the ones locals actually love.
1. Bacon, Egg, & Cheese
Few breakfasts feel as unmistakably New York as a bacon, egg, and cheese from a neighborhood deli or bodega. It's hot, filling, affordable by city standards, and easy to eat on your way somewhere else. Ordering it on a roll keeps things simple, although everyone seems to have their own preferred combination of salt, pepper, ketchup, or hot sauce.
2. Chopped Cheese
The chopped cheese has deep roots in New York's bodega culture, particularly in Harlem and the Bronx. Ground beef gets chopped on the griddle with onions and cheese before being loaded onto a hero with lettuce, tomato, and condiments. It's messy, inexpensive, and much closer to everyday New York eating than many foods marketed specifically toward visitors.
3. A Regular Cheese Slice
Forget the fancy toppings for a moment. A basic New York cheese slice remains one of the city's most dependable meals, especially when the crust is crisp underneath but still foldable. Locals aren't always searching for whichever pizzeria is currently considered the absolute best. Sometimes you just want the good slice that's two blocks away.
4. Bagel With Cream Cheese
A proper New York bagel doesn't need to be rainbow-colored or piled impossibly high with ingredients. Plenty of locals are perfectly happy with a chewy bagel, a generous schmear of cream cheese, and a cup of coffee. Whether you prefer everything, sesame, poppy, or plain is a debate that can get surprisingly personal in NYC.
5. Bodega Buttered Roll
The buttered roll may be one of the least glamorous foods associated with New York, which is precisely why visitors sometimes overlook it. It's exactly what it sounds like: a soft roll, usually toasted or warmed, with butter. For generations of commuters, students, and workers, it has been an inexpensive breakfast that you can grab without slowing down your morning.
6. Halal Cart Chicken & Rice
Chicken over rice has become an essential part of New York's street-food landscape. A typical order includes seasoned chicken, yellow rice, lettuce, and generous amounts of white sauce, with hot sauce added according to your tolerance. It's filling enough for dinner but convenient enough to eat on the go. Everyone also seems to have a favorite cart they're convinced is better than the one down the block.
7. Jamaican Beef Patties
New York's Caribbean communities have made Jamaican patties an everyday favorite in neighborhoods throughout the city. The flaky yellow pastry typically surrounds a spicy ground-beef filling, although chicken, vegetable, and other versions are easy to find. They're inexpensive, portable, and satisfying without requiring you to turn lunch into a major event.
8. Chinese Takeout
New York has extraordinary regional Chinese restaurants, but there's also plenty of affection for old-school neighborhood takeout. Dishes like chicken and broccoli, pork fried rice, and General Tso's chicken have become familiar comfort foods for generations of New Yorkers. It isn't necessarily what visitors put on their culinary bucket lists, but it's the kind of dinner locals actually order on a random Tuesday.
9. Dominican Mangu
In neighborhoods with large Dominican communities, mangu is a breakfast staple that deserves far more attention from visitors. Mashed green plantains are commonly served with eggs, fried cheese, and Dominican salami in the combination known as los tres golpes. It's hearty, savory, and deeply tied to everyday food culture in parts of Upper Manhattan and the Bronx.
10. Black-and-White Cookies
The black-and-white cookie is one tourist classic that New Yorkers haven't completely abandoned. The soft, cake-like cookie is divided between chocolate and vanilla icing, making it an easy bakery-counter treat without much fuss. It may not generate the same online excitement as a towering dessert covered in candy, but you'll still find New Yorkers happily eating them without needing to take a picture first.
KEEP ON READING
20 Foods Only Rich Kids Ate Growing Up
The Candy That Was Illegal In The US For Decades
3 Foods to Never Buy in Bulk
