×

10 Disappointing Potluck Dishes To Stop Bringing & 10 Crowd-Pleasers People Love


10 Disappointing Potluck Dishes To Stop Bringing & 10 Crowd-Pleasers People Love


Make Sure You're Invited to The Next Outing

Potluck season is right around the corner, and that means it’s time to step up your A-game! Hundreds of menu options can make one’s head spin, but a few iconic dishes have withstood the test of time, while others make people audibly groan. We’ve narrowed down which dishes you should swap—and which foods to swap them with.

Woman smiles while holding a beautiful cake.Masi Mohammadi on Unsplash

1. Pigs in a Blanket

Hang on just a minute! No pigs in a blanket at a potluck? Nothing against the little guys, it’s just that we’ve seen them too often and it’s time for a change. There are too many food options out there to limit ourselves, and there's no real way to make them unique either. 

File:American pigs in blankets.jpgPhoto credit: stef yau on Wikimedia

2. Pasta Salad

It’s not that pasta salad is a bad option, it’s that the odds of eight other people bringing the same dish are pretty high. Opt for a different choice to stand out and ensure your platter is actually clean by the end of the potluck.

Engin-Akyurt-X4Qcaodtlh0-UnsplashPhoto by engin akyurt on Unsplash

3. Sliced Fruit

Healthy, refreshing, lots of variety—fruit is well and good, but there are ways to take it to the next level. You can toss it in a salad, spear it onto skewers, or make dandy fruit cups. The idea is there, just be bold with it!

Estudio-Bloom-92Hwfhcp-Mq-UnsplashPhoto by Estúdio Bloom on Unsplash

Advertisement

4. Bagged Candy

There’s always one. You can do so much better than bringing bagged candy to a potluck, especially with so many simple and delicious meal options available. Next time you reach for a bag of Halloween candy…maybe just put it back. 

Yes-And-Studio-Xvyz Qeiebw-UnsplashPhoto by Yes and Studio on Unsplash

5. Leftovers

A potluck isn’t the time to unload your leftovers. Even if the meal you had was delicious, we all know leftovers aren’t as good two days down the line. Arrive with something fresh to give guests the best of your culinary prowess. 

Ello-Aeu9Uzstcfs-UnsplashPhoto by Ello on Unsplash

6. Tuna Salad

Tuna salad is often a potluck staple, but it’s also a common dish that can easily get swapped for something different. Not to mention, if you bring a mayonnaise-based dish—especially on a warm day—then you’re just playing with fire.

Day 242- Tuna Salad (8028465782)Sodanie Chea on Wikimedia Commons

7. Trail Mix

Trail mix is a fine thing to snack on, but it hardly screams potluck favorite. At the end of the day, it’s an option that can easily do more harm than good for people with nut allergies. It’s best to show up with food everyone (or the majority of people) can enjoy.

2021-01-06 12 15 43 Cranberry Trail Mix With Cranberries, Peanuts, Raisins, Walnuts, Almonds, Sunflower Seeds, Pepitas In The Franklin Farm Section Of Oak Hill, Fairfax County, VirginiaFamartin on Wikimedia Commons

8. Store-Bought Chips and Dip

It’s not that chips and dip will put you in the dog house, it’s that you can probably make a better dip at home that everyone will salivate over. Dip also isn’t time-consuming either, so even if you’re a busy bee, you can still try your hand at it.

Tai-S-Captures-6Cgufn39Fku-UnsplashPhoto by Tai's Captures on Unsplash

9. Steamed Vegetables

Done right, vegetables can be the life of the party. But when they’re steamed with no seasoning and left to sweat in a Tupperware container, they’re not very appetizing. Don’t be afraid to sprinkle some herbs on there, and remember that baked or grilled veggies taste far better.

Bozhin-Karaivanov-3Tmhc2Vqupk-UnsplashPhoto by Bozhin Karaivanov on Unsplash

Advertisement

10. Cheese and Crackers

Though a perfect pair, cheese and crackers can sit this one out. That said, if cheese and crackers are part of something larger, like a charcuterie board, now we’re cookin’. 

David-Kirchner-Tkztxleba14-UnsplashPhoto by David Kirchner on Unsplash

Don't you worry—there are still plenty of options you can bring! Let's dive into which dishes will make you the life of the party. 

1. Dessert

No one really expects dessert at a potluck, which is exactly why you should consider it! After all, we know you have a family recipe at home or a dish you’ve been itching to make for friends. Whip up a sweet indulgence and earn that gold star.

Sj-Ydvfndos4Iq-UnsplashPhoto by SJ 📸 on Unsplash

2. Deviled Eggs

We can’t live without deviled eggs at a potluck; it’s a classic dish at least one person should bring. What’s fun about this one is that it looks bland on the surface, but there are so many ways to make it your own. Add some lemon juice, make them spicy, fry them, or top them with meat—now’s the time to get creative!

Anton-Nikolov-Zmy2S17Cil4-UnsplashPhoto by Anton Nikolov on Unsplash

3. Turkey Pinwheels

If you’re in a rush, turkey pinwheels are a fast, healthy option. Given that they’re essentially little wraps, you also have lots of room to play around with toppings and spreads. You can even make several batches that cater to people’s dietary restrictions or tastes.

Eaters-Collective-Gg5-K-Mjwuq-UnsplashPhoto by Eaters Collective on Unsplash

4. Pulled Pork Sandwiches

Pulled pork calls our name time and again, and we see no reason to exclude them from potlucks! They’re indeed more time-consuming than your average dish, but people will undoubtedly appreciate the effort and taste.

Pulled Pork 008Christian Geischeder on Wikimedia Commons

5. Mac and Cheese

For those in need of a heartier side, mac and cheese can do no wrong. It’s one of those classic dishes that seems simple enough but actually comes with dozens of variations that truly make it unique. 

Hermes-Rivera-4Qzaer Stya-UnsplashPhoto by Hermes Rivera on Unsplash

Advertisement

6. Bruschetta

Bruschetta is a go-to appetizer for a reason. If you’re looking for a last-minute crowd-pleaser, it’s loaded with flavor and surprisingly easy to make. You can also try it with plenty of toppings, such as meats, fruit, or cheeses.

Margarita-Zueva-Spexhfb3Tfi-UnsplashPhoto by Margarita Zueva on Unsplash

7. Burger Sliders

Potlucks are incomplete without sliders, so step up and be the hero with a plate of them next time! Even if you make the patties from scratch, it doesn’t take that long, and it also gives you the chance to season them however you like.  

Carnivore-Style-Vioydd -Vya-UnsplashPhoto by Carnivore Style on Unsplash

8. Cheese Garlic Bread

Garlic bread may be hard on breath, but it’s easy on stomachs. More importantly, it deserves a spot at the potluck. Whipping up your own is easier than it sounds, and it doesn’t take much time either. Melt a little cheese on there and don’t expect any leftovers.

Waldemar-Zevnvcuyijg-UnsplashPhoto by Waldemar on Unsplash

9. Cauliflower Bites

Not everyone’s a fan of cauliflower, but toss them in a little seasoning (or sauce) and stick them in the oven to change people’s minds! Whether you make them spicy or keep things mild, you’re looking at a hit. 

Louis-Hansel-9Iqqvep0Szc-UnsplashPhoto by Louis Hansel on Unsplash

10. Caprese Skewers

Potlucks need Caprese (sorry, we don’t make the rules). A Caprese salad is always welcome, but there’s something about skewers that brings out the biggest appetite. You don’t need much either: cheese, cherry tomatoes, balsamic drizzle, and fresh basil.

Benjamin-Brunner-Ehfmfjvkmn4-UnsplashPhoto by Benjamin Brunner on Unsplash

Summary Of Changes

  • There’s always one. You can do so much better than bringing bagged candy to a potluck, especially with so many simple and delicious meal options available. Next time you reach for a bag of Halloween candy…maybe just put it back.  changed to There's always one. You can do so much better than bringing bagged candy to a potluck, especially with so many simple and delicious meal options available. Next time you reach for a bag of Halloween candy...maybe just put it back.
  • dog house changed to doghouse
  • Dip also isn’t time-consuming either changed to Dip also isn't time-consuming
  • we’re cookin’ changed to we're cooking
  • at a potluck; it’s a classic dish at least one person should bring. changed to at a potluck; it's a classic dish that at least one person should bring.
  • Pulled pork calls our name time and again, and we see no reason to exclude them from potlucks! They’re indeed more time-consuming than your average dish, but people will undoubtedly appreciate the effort and taste. changed to Pulled pork calls our name time and again, and we see no reason to exclude it from potlucks! It's indeed more time-consuming than your average dish, but people will undoubtedly appreciate the effort and taste.
  • fruit changed to fruits
  • Garlic bread may be hard on breath, but it’s easy on stomachs. changed to Garlic bread may be hard on the breath, but it's easy on the stomach.
  • them changed to it