×

10 Condiments That Contain a Surprising Amount of Sugar & 10 Better Choices


10 Condiments That Contain a Surprising Amount of Sugar & 10 Better Choices


A Little Sauce Can Add Up Faster Than You Think

Condiments may not seem like a major source of sugar, but those spoonfuls and squeezes can quietly increase your daily intake. Many popular sauces rely on added sugar to balance acidity, boost flavor, or improve shelf life, making them sweeter than most people realize. That doesn't mean you have to give up sauces, but accessorizing your sandwiches differently can make a big difference. Here are 10 condiments with a surprising amount of added sugar and 10 better alternatives.

1784155231e6e1910838d3a6f71060d84ddf2ccba4fc8fed08.jpegAlena Shekhovtcova on Pexels


1. Ketchup

Ketchup may seem harmless because most people use it in small amounts, but it's often sweetened with added sugar or high-fructose corn syrup. Just a couple of tablespoons can contain around 8 grams of sugar, depending on the brand. If you use it on fries, burgers, and eggs throughout the day, those servings can add up quickly. 

1784154514109c16118abcf942d718dafd540a7c89ac28de4e.jpgErik Mclean on Unsplash

2. Barbecue Sauce

Barbecue sauce is one of the sweetest condiments on grocery store shelves. Many varieties contain molasses, brown sugar, honey, or corn syrup near the top of the ingredient list. That sweetness works well with smoky flavors, but it also means a small serving can pack a surprising amount of sugar. 

17841545505f466de17d7bf788a189f6651ea63814ba9a060c.jpgAddilyn Ragsdill @clockworklemon.com on Unsplash

3. Sweet Chili Sauce

Sweet chili sauce makes no attempt to hide its sugary side. It's designed to balance heat with sweetness, which is why sugar is usually one of the primary ingredients.

Advertisement

A modest drizzle can contribute several grams of added sugar to your meal.

1784154774ac860bd38f8ee343ded7883165f02af52995b4d6.jpegNadin Sh on Pexels

4. Teriyaki Sauce

Teriyaki sauce gets much of its signature flavor from sugar combined with soy sauce and seasonings. The sweetness helps create its glossy texture and caramelized finish when cooked. While it's great for marinades and stir-fries, many bottled versions contain more added sugar than people expect. 

1784154792f11973653f94310f2abef2b4f17134c8f648e376.jpegAnya Dunes on Pexels

5. Honey Mustard

Honey mustard sounds healthier because mustard itself is naturally low in sugar. However, the addition of honey, sugar, or other sweeteners often changes the nutritional picture considerably. Depending on the brand, it can contain several teaspoons of sugar in just a few servings.

178415482325c9d38eb05925b26650ea5194eb99cf28c976c4.jpgTaurusEmerald on Wikimedia

6. Duck Sauce

Duck sauce is commonly served with Chinese takeout, but its sweet flavor comes from generous amounts of sugar or fruit concentrates. The bright orange color may grab your attention first, yet it's the sweetness that dominates the taste. A few packets can contribute more sugar than you intended. 

17841548536d672dbfebc2f3620c3e1a4c69fd6edbd56908f7.jpgThe original uploader was Plastik klinik at English Wikipedia. on Wikimedia

7. Cocktail Sauce

Cocktail sauce combines ketchup with horseradish and other seasonings, so it naturally inherits much of ketchup's sugar content. Although the spicy kick distracts your taste buds, the sweetness is still there. Seafood lovers often use several tablespoons without thinking much about it, but those portions can quietly increase your added sugar intake.

1784154878104204aa2448e63820b83faaf283ec0bfba0dbe7.jpgsheri silver on Unsplash

8. Sweet Relish

Sweet pickle relish is another condiment that earns its name honestly.

Advertisement

Sugar is a major ingredient in most recipes, giving it the familiar sweet-and-tangy flavor people enjoy on hot dogs and burgers. Even small spoonfuls contribute more sugar than regular dill relish. 

178415490513a1a595a134389ed4d991263987295ebdadfe05.jpgTaurusEmerald on Wikimedia

9. Hoisin Sauce

Hoisin sauce delivers rich, savory flavor, but it's also surprisingly sweet. Many recipes rely on sugar alongside fermented soybeans and spices to create their signature taste. Because it's often used generously in stir-fries, wraps, and dipping sauces, the sugar content can add up. 

1784154950bdc1cd80e9134ed560d824c143fd9cf3e85c7089.jpgAmanda Lim on Unsplash

10. Russian Dressing

Russian dressing combines ketchup, mayonnaise, and sweet ingredients into one creamy condiment. While it pairs well with sandwiches and salads, the ketchup base contributes more sugar than many creamy dressings. Different brands vary quite a bit, so comparing labels can be worthwhile. 

17841549764e8f7328436de93aecc02ca96471e26213abea95.jpgrick on Wikimedia

Now that we've covered the condiments that hide added sugar, let's talk about some of the healthier options.

1. Yellow Mustard

Yellow mustard contains very little sugar in most traditional recipes. Its bold, tangy flavor makes it an easy substitute for sweeter condiments on sandwiches and burgers. You don't need much to make an impact, which helps keep portions small. 

178415501602c003cb417158ec84a8365617a3ccbf23869581.jpgPedro Durigan on Unsplash

2. Dijon Mustard

Dijon mustard delivers a sharper, more complex flavor than standard yellow mustard while remaining low in sugar. It works well in salad dressings, marinades, and sandwiches without relying on sweetness.

Advertisement

The stronger taste often means you use less overall. 

1784155053f59e9a0c4f8f7a350e482e33dfb6021c44c4e2c0.JPGAnton Lefterov on Wikimedia

3. Plain Mayonnaise

Plain mayonnaise contains very little sugar in most traditional varieties. While it's higher in fat than some other condiments, it isn't usually a significant source of added sugar. Choosing regular mayonnaise instead of sweet sandwich spreads can help lower your sugar intake, but as always, moderation still matters.

17841550715381eeb9dc2461f2e78002674532bb5a60ba8ed3.jpegWallace Castro on Pexels

4. Salsa

Fresh tomato salsa adds plenty of flavor with relatively little sugar. Tomatoes, onions, peppers, herbs, and lime juice create a bright combination that works with tacos, grilled meats, eggs, and even salads. Many refrigerated salsas contain little or no added sugar. 

178415509297290cb389201269b77bb5ccc3286a5ccb31dec9.jpgMandy Bourke on Unsplash

5. Pesto

Traditional pesto gets its rich flavor from basil, olive oil, garlic, Parmesan cheese, and pine nuts rather than sugar. It adds freshness to pasta, sandwiches, vegetables, and grilled chicken without relying on sweetness. A small spoonful goes a long way because the flavors are so bold. 

1784155127d168ffc2becdb0655c731a31d7d7349c2db2c588.jpgMagnus Jonasson on Unsplash

6. Tzatziki

Tzatziki combines Greek yogurt, cucumber, garlic, dill, and lemon into a creamy sauce that's naturally low in sugar. It pairs beautifully with grilled meats, vegetables, and wraps while adding plenty of freshness, and the yogurt provides richness and protein.

178415514397dd730c2efc73747d4369116b4e1a4a695b2586.jpgMor Shani on Unsplash

7. Guacamole

Guacamole relies on avocados, lime juice, onions, tomatoes, and herbs for its flavor instead of added sugar. Its creamy texture makes it an excellent topping for tacos, sandwiches, and grain bowls.

Advertisement

You also get healthy fats that help make meals more satisfying.

178415516058d85ce455238f531c87069bb505196b967f8f96.jpgyakshi virmani on Unsplash

8. Chimichurri

Chimichurri is packed with parsley, garlic, olive oil, vinegar, and herbs, making it naturally free of added sugar in most recipes. It brings vibrant flavor to grilled steak, chicken, seafood, and vegetables. Because it's herb-based, every bite tastes fresh rather than sweet. 

1784155177908fad90c6a84de67ff930c419fbeb355a621b58.jpgamirali mirhashemian on Unsplash

9. Hot Sauce

Most traditional hot sauces contain very little or no added sugar. They rely on peppers, vinegar, and spices to deliver flavor instead of sweetness. A few drops can completely transform a meal without significantly increasing your sugar intake. 

17841551979528c341f8b192ceacc650cb49a47faa6d2909b2.jpgYi Wei on Unsplash

10. Hummus

Although technically more of a spread than a classic condiment, hummus makes an excellent substitute for many sugary sandwich toppings and dips. It's made primarily from chickpeas, tahini, olive oil, lemon juice, and garlic, with very little naturally occurring sugar. The creamy texture and savory flavor make it versatile enough for vegetables, wraps, sandwiches, and crackers. 

178415521115f30ad87047aa5ca68d73e3b4b4a39932402ba0.jpgLudovic Avice on Unsplash