×

The 20 Best Desserts That Use Reese's Peanut Butter Cups


The 20 Best Desserts That Use Reese's Peanut Butter Cups


“Two Great Tastes That Taste Great Together”

Before we begin, let’s all take a moment to reflect on this iconic duo; it’s simple, it’s delicious, and it’s wowed our tastebuds since 1928! Though we love this classic pairing, it’s time to think outside the box a little—say hello to 20 desserts that put Reese’s Cups to even better use. 

File:Gfp-peanut-butter-candy.jpgYinan Chen on Wikimedia

1. Chocolate “Chip” Cookies

Everybody likes chocolate chip cookies, but you can elevate them with everyone’s favorite snack, too! Instead of chocolate chips, use Reese’s candy pieces or crushed peanut butter cups; you’ll add a decadent flavor with just one ingredient swap. 

cookies on white ceramic plateDaniel Lopez on Unsplash

2. Cheesecake

Who doesn’t want to sink their fork into a mouthwatering slice of cheesecake? The best thing about this dessert is its versatility, which allows you to combine a wide range of ingredients and flavors. You’ll need a few hours and all the usual ingredients like cream cheese, heavy cream, and vanilla—only now you’ll also have chopped Reese’s cups. 

chocolate cake beside strawberries and wine glassAllen Rad on Unsplash

3. Fudge Squares

As much as we love brownies, good fudge hits the palate a little differently. The only thing that could make it any better is Reese’s, which is why you should toss them in with milk and peanut butter. You can also use white chocolate chips or a pinch of salt to crank it up a notch.

Elle HughesElle Hughes on Pexels

Advertisement

4. Peanut Butter Cookies

We’re halfway to peanut butter cups with these cookies, so you might as well make the leap! It doesn’t take more than a few ingredients to make a batch of these cookies, and your only additional step is to top them with sugar and mini Reese’s cups.

brown cookies in black ceramic bowlDiliara Garifullina on Unsplash

5. Stuffed Cupcakes

You know what’s better than a cupcake? Cupcakes with delicious fillings! All you have to do is place mini Reese’s cups into the batter before you bake them. Top with peanut butter frosting and chocolate sprinkles for two desserts in one.

person holds tray of muffins on trayTaylor Grote on Unsplash

6. Banana Bread

Who knew banana bread could get any better? By mixing chopped Reese’s cups into the batter, you’ll score a rich bread loaf brimming with additional flavor. It’s moist, it’s rich, and you bet it’ll be gone before the week’s up. 

a loaf of banana nut bread sitting on top of a wooden cutting boardCody Chan on Unsplash

7. Milkshake

With summertime officially around the corner, nothing beats a refreshing milkshake. If you want to step away from the traditional flavors, look no further than a Reese’s blend. Simply grab vanilla (or chocolate) ice cream, some milk, and a few chopped cups for a creamy brew that goes down smooth. 

Pavel DanilyukPavel Danilyuk on Pexels

8. Mini Cheesecake

Cheesecake is great, but there’s something about mini cheesecake that makes us feel a little less guilty. The major difference between this and the traditional stuff is that the baby version is better for gatherings! Top it with chocolate whipped cream or Reese’s candy for that added touch. 

ready madeready made on Pexels

9. Homemade McFlurry

You’re never going to find a working ice cream machine, so you might as well make McFlurries at home. Grab you mixer, some crushed Reese Cups, and a handful of Nutter Butters for a crunchy copycat that beats McDonald’s.

File:McFlurry with Reese's Closerup (6518548625).jpgtheimpulsivebuy on Wikimedia

Advertisement

10. Cookie Dough

Don’t worry—we’re not advocating for salmonella! With the right ingredients, however, you can make homemade cookie dough without the guilt or risk of bacteria. Flour, vanilla, brown sugar, and butter help you get there, and chopped Reese’s cups make it even better.

brown and white pastry on white ceramic plateBen Stein on Unsplash

11. Brownies

We couldn’t make this list without mentioning brownies. You can handle these the same way you’d handle cupcakes: place a mini Reese’s cup in the batter before baking! While you certainly won’t need more than that, you can also top with sprinkles or homemade frosting for an extra sweet treat.

File:Reese's Pieces brownie.jpgBryan Ochalla on Wikimedia

12. Pretzel Bites

Sometimes you need salty and sweet. Enter Reese’s pretzel bites: a no-fuss dessert made with just pretzel squares and mini Reese’s cups. Simply place the cup on top and pop them in the oven for about two minutes. You can top them with a Reese’s candy as well, but you don’t have to!

brown bread on white ceramic bowlEiliv Aceron on Unsplash

13. Ice Cream

Why splurge on grocery store ice cream when you can just make your own at home? Patience is a virtue with this one because you’ll need several hours for a proper chill. However, you won’t need more than a handful of ingredients to get the job done—milk, heavy cream, sugar, and chopped Reese’s cups will do just fine.

Barb LandroBarb Landro on Pexels

14. Hot Chocolate

We know it seems weird to pound back hot chocolate in the summertime, but don’t knock it ‘til you try it. Cocoa powder, milk, and mini Reese’s cups create a chocolate explosion in your mug, and it’s one we’d sip year-round. 

Chocolate coffeeJonny Caspari on Unsplash

15. S'mores

Traditional s’mores are a camping staple, but could we interest you in a simple swap? Ditch the milk chocolate for Reese’s cups! It’s an easy alternative that gives extra oomph to a beloved campfire snack. 

woman holding biscuitAutumn Mott Rodeheaver on Unsplash

Advertisement

16. Thumbprint Cookies

Until now, many people opted for Hershey’s Kisses as their thumbprint. It’s time to turn the recipe on its head with mini Reese’s cups instead! Even with the new addition, you won’t sink your teeth into an overly sweet cookie—the mini cups don’t go overboard.

close photography of biscuits with chocolatesMadison Kaminski on Unsplash

17. Chocolate Cake

It’s hard to “improve” chocolate cake, but Reese’s cups don’t make it any worse! Whether it’s mini cups on top or crushed cups throughout the layers, you can play with this recipe to make it all your own. 

File:Peanut butter chocolate cake decoraded with Reese's (49081993628).jpgHelena Jacoba on Wikimedia

18. Peanut Butter Fluff

Say hello to your new favorite fluff. Made with basic ingredients like cream cheese, pudding, milk, and mini Reese’s cups, you can incorporate it with other desserts or grab a spoonful all on its own.  

Photo By: Kaboompics.comPhoto By: Kaboompics.com on Pexels

19. Dessert Pizza

No one ever said no to a fresh pie, especially a dessert one! You won’t need much besides a little dough, some chocolate, and Reese’s cups to bring this vision to life. You can also add melted peanut butter drizzle or Reese’s candy bits to tie it all together.

File:Pizza a2.jpgCYAN on Wikimedia

20. Stuffed Cookies

Cookies are good, but stuffed cookies are better. Think of a chocolate chip cookie with a Reese’s peanut butter cup smack dab in the middle. Pretty incredible, right? With classic ingredients like flour, brown sugar, and baking soda, you can whip up a batch with stuff already in the pantry. 

File:Who doesn't love peanut butter cups?.jpgBryan Ochalla on Wikimedia