When Pizza Night Takes a Drastic Turn
Pizza is supposed to be the safe choice, the crowd-pleaser, the thing everyone can agree on when nobody wants to cook. But put olives and anchovies on that pie, and you can pretty much guarantee all but one (you, probably) will stay in the room. As delicious as a cheesy slice can be, not everything is welcome on top and in every bite. So, the next time you order delivery, be sure not to include any of these 20 diabolical toppings.
1. Mushrooms
Mushrooms have a way of taking over a pizza: since they release moisture as they cook, they can leave the cheese feeling heavier and the crust less crisp than it should be. Even people who like mushrooms in other dishes often hesitate when they see them scattered across a pizza. There’s just something about their texture against melted cheese that doesn’t win people over.
David Foodphototasty on Unsplash
2. Olives
Olives are one of those toppings that people immediately turn their nose up at. Their salty, briny flavor doesn’t blend into the background, so you either want them there or you spend the whole slice wishing they weren’t. Black olives can feel especially intense when they’re warmed up and spread across cheese. Green olives are even more divisive, because they add an extra sharpness that can make the whole pizza taste off-balance.
3. Sardines
Sardines may have their fans, but putting them on pizza is asking a lot from everyone else in the room. Their strong fishy flavor doesn’t fade under cheese or sauce, and it can make every bite feel heavier than expected. The texture also isn’t doing the pizza any favors, especially when it clashes with a chewy crust.
4. Anchovies
Like sardines, anchovies are probably the most famous “please don’t” pizza topping, and their reputation is well earned. They’re extremely salty, intensely savory, and difficult to ignore once they’ve touched a slice. Even picking them off doesn’t always solve the problem, because the oil and flavor tend to linger. A few people love that punch, but for everyone else, anchovies can ruin an otherwise perfectly good pizza.
5. Sauerkraut
Sauerkraut on pizza feels like a choice. A bad choice, that is. Its sourness cuts through the cheese so aggressively that the sauce barely gets a chance to shine. The texture can also be strange on a hot slice, especially when it’s piled on thick. It may work for a very specific craving, but most people aren’t looking for fermented cabbage when they order pizza.
6. Canned Tuna
Canned tuna is great in a sandwich, but on pizza it becomes much harder to defend. The smell gets stronger when heated (that means your mouth will smell, too), and the flavor spreads quickly through the cheese. It can also make the whole slice feel dry and oddly dense, especially if there isn’t enough sauce to balance it. You might understand why someone tried it once, but you probably don’t need to experience it yourself.
7. Avocado
Avocado sounds like it should work because it’s creamy and rich, but pizza doesn’t always treat it kindly. Once it warms up, the texture can feel mushy and just gross. It also tends to mute the brighter flavors of sauce, cheese, and herbs rather than adding much of its own. On a fresh salad or toast, avocado makes sense; on a hot pizza, it often feels misplaced.
8. Spinach
Spinach can look harmless, but it has a habit of making pizza feel damp and a little too earthy. When it wilts under cheese, it loses the freshness people might have been hoping for. It can also clump together, leaving some bites overloaded and others completely untouched.
9. Broccoli
Broccoli on pizza often feels like someone tried to make dinner more virtuous and forgot what pizza is supposed to be. The florets can dry out, turn mushy, burn at the edges, or trap bits of sauce and cheese in ways that don’t always taste pleasant. Its flavor also stands apart from the rest of the slice instead of settling into it. You can enjoy broccoli in plenty of places, but pizza is rarely where it shines.
10. Artichoke Hearts
Artichoke hearts appear on enough specialty pizzas to seem respectable, but they still divide the room; their tangy, slightly bitter flavor can overwhelm milder toppings and make the cheese taste less comforting. They also have a soft, fibrous texture that not everyone wants on a slice. When they’re used sparingly, they’re tolerable, but once they become the main event, you might have the whole room up in arms.
11. Eggplant
Eggplant has potential in many dishes, but pizza exposes all of its weaknesses. If it isn’t cooked properly beforehand, it can turn spongy, oily, or strangely bland. Even when it’s prepared well, it often feels too soft against the crust and cheese. A topping shouldn’t make the slice feel heavier without making it more satisfying, and eggplant often does exactly that.
12. Pickles
Believe it or not, pickles have become more common on pizza, especially on cheeseburger-style pies, but they’re still a hard, hard sell for a lot of people. Their sour, vinegary bite can overwhelm the sauce and cheese almost immediately. They also bring a wet crunch that doesn’t always feel right on a hot slice. Some people love the sharpness, but others feel like pickles belong firmly on the side.
13. Brussels Sprouts
Sure, Brussels sprouts can be great when they’re roasted properly, but pizza isn’t always the best place for them. If they’re undercooked, they can taste bitter and tough; if they’re overdone, they can dominate the whole slice. Their strong flavor also competes with the sauce instead of blending into it.
14. Jalapeños
Jalapeños are common enough to be ordinary, but that doesn’t mean they’re universally welcome. Their heat can take over fairly quickly, especially when the slices are scattered unevenly and one bite becomes much stronger than the next. They’re fine for people who asked for them, but they shouldn’t be added like a harmless default.
15. Fresh Fruits
Fresh fruits like blueberries, strawberries, and bananas can make pizza feel like a confusing mush. Their sweetness doesn’t always work with tomato sauce, melted cheese, or savory toppings. They can also release moisture as they sit, which makes the slice feel messy and uneven. Dessert pizza is one thing, but fresh fruit on a regular pizza is where many people draw the line.
16. Raw Tomatoes
Raw tomatoes seem innocent enough, but they can make pizza feel watery and mushy. Instead of melting into the sauce or roasting into something richer, they often sit on top as cool, slippery slices. That temperature and texture contrast can be distracting when the rest of the pizza is hot and cheesy. Even tomato lovers may prefer them cooked, sauced, or left off entirely.
17. Hot Dogs
Hot dogs on pizza sound like they should appeal to anyone who likes salty comfort food, but the result can be a lot. The flavor is strong, processed, and hard to balance with sauce and cheese. Sliced pieces can also make the pizza feel heavier without making it better. It may work for a novelty order, but honestly, keep your hot dogs in the buns.
18. Corn
Corn has become more common on pizza in some places, but it still feels like a confusing addition to many people. Its sweetness doesn’t always match the sauce, and the kernels can make each bite feel strangely uneven. The texture is also distracting, especially when you’re expecting a smooth mix of crust, cheese, and toppings.
19. Marshmallows and Sweets
Dessert pizza has its audience, but marshmallows and candy-style toppings can push it into territory that feels more weird than delicious. The sweetness piles up quickly, especially when it’s paired with frosting, chocolate, or sugary sauces. Marshmallows can also become sticky and overly soft, making the whole thing harder to eat than it should be.
20. Pineapple
Pineapple is the final boss of divisive pizza toppings for a reason. Its sweetness clashes with tomato sauce for many people, and the juicy texture can make a slice feel soggier than expected. Fans will defend it forever, but opponents aren’t just being dramatic when they say it changes the whole pie. Whether it’s paired with ham or scattered on its own, pineapple remains the topping most likely to turn pizza night into an argument.
KEEP ON READING
20 Soups and Stews That Get Better Overnight
